Solid wood vs. fiberboard cabinets: what's actually in the box

Solid wood dovetail drawer box on an E&B cabinet

Shop for cabinets online and you'll see the same white shaker door a hundred times. In a photo, a $330 cabinet and an $800 cabinet can look exactly alike. The difference shows up later: when a drawer gets loaded with pots, when a sink cabinet sees a leak, or when you try to rehang a wall cabinet and the screws won't hold.

Here's what to look at before you buy, so you can compare cabinets on what's inside instead of on the photo.

1. Doors and boxes: solid wood or fiberboard?

Many online cabinets use HDF or MDF for the doors. Those are engineered fiberboards: wood fibers pressed together with glue. They paint smoothly and they're cheap, which is why they're common. The tradeoff is that fiberboard swells if water gets into an edge or a screw hole, and screws strip out more easily when hinges are adjusted or reset.

Boxes vary too. Some sellers use plywood, which is good. Others use particleboard, which is the weakest of the three around moisture.

What to look for: the listing should name the material for the door, the face frame and the box. If it only says "wood construction" or doesn't say, ask.

E&B cabinets are solid wood construction, and every cabinet page lists the wood. Most of our colors are birch.

2. Drawers: dovetail or stapled?

Drawers take more abuse than anything else in a kitchen. A stapled or glued drawer box can loosen at the corners after a few years of heavy pans. Dovetail joints lock the sides together so the box stays square.

Check the slides as well. Undermount slides hide under the drawer, run smoother and usually carry more weight than side-mount slides. Full extension means you can reach the back of the drawer.

Our drawer boxes are solid wood with dovetail joints, on full extension undermount soft-close slides rated to 90 lb.

3. Hinges and wall hangers

Soft-close hinges are standard now, but adjustability isn't. Six-way adjustable hinges let you line up doors perfectly after install, which matters when floors and walls aren't square (they never are).

For wall cabinets, look at how they hang. Plastic hangers or screwing straight through a thin back panel puts all the weight on a weak spot. Galvanized steel hangers spread the load and make leveling easier.

4. Flat-pack or assembled?

A lot of online cabinets ship flat-pack. Plan on one to two hours per cabinet to build them, or a fee per cabinet if the seller assembles them. For a 20-cabinet kitchen, that's a weekend or more before installation even starts.

E&B cabinets ship fully assembled by liftgate freight, wrapped and strapped to pallets. You unwrap them, set them and install them.

5. The real price

When you compare prices, add up the whole project:

  • Freight. Many sellers quote freight at checkout. Ours is one flat charge for the whole order, and free on orders of $3,000 or more.
  • Assembly. Your time, or a per-cabinet fee.
  • The "was" price. If a cabinet is always 50 to 70% off, the original price was never real. We list our actual price, and bigger orders save $200 to $1,250 automatically at checkout.

The quick checklist

  • Door, face frame and box material named on the listing
  • Dovetail drawer boxes on undermount, full extension slides
  • Soft-close, adjustable hinges
  • Steel wall hangers
  • Ships assembled, or the assembly cost added to the price
  • Freight included in your comparison

Want to see the difference in person? Order a sample door, send us your measurements and our designer will plan your project, or browse kitchens by style.

rather not measure twice?
Send your sketch. You get a layout and a priced cabinet list. $200 deposit, credited to your order.
Get a layout design